Location: Shelby
Top Restaurants in Shelby
Top Things to do in Shelby
Countries
Best American food near Shelby, Montana, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in Shelby, Montana, United States. Shelby is a city in and the county seat of Toole County, Montana, United States. The population was 3,376 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Shelby
7. Montana Club
Absolutely the best burgers around! And don't forget to check out our nightly specials!!
Reviewed By 12LarryH
Riding my motorcycle to Alaska and spending the night in Shelby MT. Ask lady at the Sherlock Motel where to eat She said the Montana Club had the best burgers, so I walked there. Now first let me say it is an old school BAR! They serve bar food and the burger was big and great. Fries were hand cut. My burger was maybe over a 1/2 pound. Total for burger & fries plus an Angry Orchard was $12.00. An older couple walked in and ask where is the restaurant part was.and the cute bartender told them it was mainly a BAR that serves food and she told them of other restaurants in town. They decided to go to one she recommended
6. Subway
Reviewed By Ceilon A
We love Subway for sandwiches but had never tried their breakfast. It turned out to be very good. Everything you'd expect from a Subway custom sandwich only with breakfast options (egg, bacon, etc.--they were out of ham). The counter staff was pleasant, but had a sort of deadpan humor that only people like my husband "get." Nice fellow, but be prepared if you aren't into deadpan humor.
5. Pizza Hut
Overall Ratings
3 based on 53 reviews
Reviewed By Marmoore66
We had first been told to eat at a couple of other restaurants, but truthfully, one looked like a ragged shack, and the other was more of a bar than a family restaurant, so we opted to try Pizza Hut. First, the person who took our order and the server were helpful and friendly, and second, the food was delicious. It was served timely, and we were impressed as to how each Pizza Hut was different. This one definitely deserves a 5 star.
4. Dash Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 26 reviews
Reviewed By Heather P
We're traveling with adults, kids, & a dog, which makes eating together a challenge. This was perfect for our group as we were able to all eat together at the picnic table outside! You can pull up & someone will come out & take your order OR you can order at the window like we did & then sit at one of the picnic tables in their lovely yard with beautiful flowers & green grass! The kids & dog loved the chance to move around a bit while the adults sat & talked. The food was great & the price was comprable to what our family spends when we go to any other 'fast' food place, but with higher quality food!
3. The Griddle
Overall Ratings
4 based on 62 reviews
Family friendly restaurant. Efficient staff who treats you like family!! Amazing food! People love our home made soups, we have weekly breakfast specials, daily lunch and dinner specials, and give our home made pies a try they melt in your mouth!!
Reviewed By C7712VCpaull
Had my doubts walking in but those were soon cleared up. Older clientele, on a Sunday morning. Turns out they had eaten and were just visiting. Young staff (&music) very nicely, helpful and efficient. Food was good, not stunningly excellent but good. Very happily I will return to the Griddle.
2. The Alibi Lounge
Overall Ratings
4 based on 62 reviews
Reviewed By Taylor B
Alibi Lounge is a sports bar that is advertised as the best restaurant in Shelby, Montana, according to TripAdvisor and other culinary critics. Most people are lured by the pizza, which comes in many versions with many toppings and, by most accounts, is as good as gold. As native Chicagoans, from a town that prides itself on thin crust and deep dish pizza, we are snobs on the subject, always skeptical that anyone outside the Windy City knows how to put together a real pizza. But, in our extensive travels, we have learned that they do. Even in Shelby, Montana. How's that for snobbishness? My wife and I had a long lunch at the Alibi Lounge and came away convinced that it is the No. 1 dining experience in town. We sampled garlic bread, chicken tenders and a chopped salad with crispy iceberg lettuce, pepperoni, onion, tomato, black olives, fresh basil and parmesan cheese tossed with Italian dressing. My wife had breaded chicken, four pieces of fresh broasted chicken with fries. I couldn't resist an Alibi burger, 1/2 pound of gourmet brisket chuck blend topped with bacon, sauteed onions and mushrooms, pepper jack and beer cheese, jalapenos, secret Alibi sauce and French fried onions on a pretzel bun. Finally, we tested a pizza, Mike's Special, with sausage, green peppers and onion with marinara sauce. Two thumbs up from those Chicago snobs. And my wife also gave a thumbs up to Alibi Lounge's clean rest room, always an important item on her restaurant check list.
1. Frontier Bar and Supper Club
Overall Ratings
4 based on 77 reviews
Reviewed By Tony N
Very old building and you would be very surprised to find such excellent food here. I have been to many high end restaurants and have not had this quality. The ambience is great and so are the staff. The portions are huge, so you had better go there with an empty stomach. Recommended - Prime Rib.
