Location: New Carlisle
Top Restaurants in New Carlisle
Top Things to do in New Carlisle
Countries
Best American food near New Carlisle, Indiana, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in New Carlisle, Indiana, United States. New Carlisle is a suburban town in Olive Township, St. Joseph County, in the U.S. state of Indiana. The population was 1,861 at the 2010 Census. It is part of the South Bend–Mishawaka, IN-MI, Metropolitan Statistical Area.
Things to do in New Carlisle
10. Carriage House Dining Room & Gardens
Overall Ratings
4 based on 287 reviews
Indiana's most nationally recognized restaurant - 28 years AAA Chicago Four Diamond and 30 years Wine Spectator "Award of Excellence." Formal Main Dining housed within historical 1851 building featuring the freshest farm-to-table foods and extensive fine
Reviewed By ginidick
We went to Carriage House last night for a light repast. We ordered the soup du jour and appetizers and a bottle of wine. The food, the service, the atmosphere was all wonderful. Looking forward to coming back & having their special French themed dinner.
9. Froehlich's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
Froehlichâs Bakery & Deli is well known as the destination for people who prefer Simple, Fresh, Nourishing, & Authentically Delicious Food. During the past 25 years weâve enjoyed collaborating with local farmers & foodies in a way that allows us to provid
Reviewed By NXTTRP
In town on a family matter, we lunched at Froehlichâs and very much enjoyed the experience. Historically a bakery, which still exists directly across the street, we ate lunch in what appears to be a retrofitted department store facility, complete with the stamped sheet metal ceiling tiles. This is a very well done remodel, with clean, modern lines and a menu with a wide range of options. I donât suspect cocktails were served at the original bakery so thatâs an addition as well. Members of our group enjoyed shrimp poâ boy and grilled cheese sandwiches, hamburgers and salads. Everything seemed to be very well received. Froehlichâs is easy to find in this small village and itâs close enough to the interstate to drive over for lunch and a change of pace. A stroll down the main drag will put you in a different place. Certainly Iâll remember that option. I only wish I could have justified purchases from the bakery as all their fare was mouthwatering.
8. Starbucks
Reviewed By moerke
The long line should have been a warning that things were moving slow! The barista at the register whined to her coworkers about needing a break the entire time we waited. The barista making the drinks was more obsessed about wiping and re-wiping the counter, leaving drinks in the blender containers while she picked napkins and other garbage up off the floor and even off her shoes, we left when she went back to pouring drinks without washing her hands. This was a perfect example of workers who hate their job and want those around them to know it.
7. Journeyman Distillery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 156 reviews
Journeyman Distillery is an Organic Distillery, located in the EK Warren historic featherbone factory, in Three Oaks, Michigan. We offer handcrafted artisan spirits with a focus on whiskey. Our products come from the simplest, purest ingredients on earth.
Reviewed By L4858OPjacks
My wife had cabbage soup and I had a pulled pork sandwich. Both were great. Neat place to eat. Weâll be back. We highly recommend that you stop here if youâre in the area.
6. Bob's 19th Hole
Overall Ratings
4 based on 108 reviews
Bob's 19th Hole has been serving great food to the Michiana area since 1976. We Strive to serve the best quality at the most reasonable price. If you have ever enjoyed our food, please tell others. If you haven't, please tell us!
Reviewed By wykert
We showed up about 6:30pm on a Monday evening, looking for an easy meal. The dining room was pretty full and there was just one waitress on in that section even though there were plenty of employees on premise. Delay in being greeted, rushed service, plates were not cleared away, average food for our family of four. Certainly not the Certificate of Excellence I expected.
5. Nowhere Bar and Grill
Reviewed By FiveOaks61
We went on a Friday night as Nowhere had been known for a good fish dinner. My daughter, son- in-law and two granddaughters, wife and I. It was like walking into an ashtray. They have changed their policy to smoking and no children. We were only to happy to leave.
4. Heston Supper Club
Overall Ratings
4 based on 307 reviews
Prime rib, seafood & wine in a former tavern converted into a cozy, upscale eatery.
Reviewed By ScottWhitfield
What can I say? A 14-ounce prime rib that melts in your mouth, fresh, perfectly cooked vegetables, and true service with a SMILE. Yum!! Go there! You'll thank me! :>)
3. Jennie Rae's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
We were in this little town for a volleyball tournament and were so pleasantly surprised by this great family restaurant! We actually ate there twice in 1 day, an entire groupnof parents and girls. Everyone enjoyed it! Check out the hours though.
Reviewed By FiveOaks61
This is a locally owned and run breakfast and lunch place. A local hangout but not surprising to see license plates from any of the 50 states. Sitting right on the highway it is an easy stop. All your breakfast and lunch favorites are available huge pancakes, omelets, home fries and biscuits and gravy, burgers and fries or lunch specials. Booths, tables and a lunch counter are tended by some very pleasant waitresses that make sure your coffee cup is always full. There is nothing fancy here just great food and service.
2. Billy Goat 9 & Dine
Reviewed By Mar L
Thanks to Trip Advisor, we tried this place for pizza. We didn't even know it was here!! It is a little hidden. You have to turn off of Michigan and come in the back entrance. We did not know where we were going and entered in the exit driveway off of Michigan. Well, luckily nobody was driving out! The place was bustling on a Saturday night and we were very pleased with the friendly service and delicious pizza. We used to go to Stevetty's for pizza and couldn't find anything close to that quality until now!!
1. Kate O'Connor's Irish Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 50 reviews
Reviewed By Dave C
I am Irish and Scottish so after hearing good things from friends we had to try it. I ordered the Irish Egg Rolls appetizer, huge portion, a meal in itself, very good. I also ordered a cup of Irish Potato soup with a mashed potato scoop in the middle, amazing creamy cold weather comfort soup. I do NOT drink beer, never have, do not like the taste or smell, but I asked our server if I could have a small sample of the Guiness, I was surprised that I actually liked the taste, to me it had a kind of coffee, chocolate, creamy after taste, I wouldn't drink a whole pint but I liked the taste I had. I ordered the Brisket sandwich after our very friendly server Alexis told us they cook and smoke the beef brisket, ribs, etc... on-site. The brisket was perfectly cooked, firm but falling apart moist and tender. I can hardly wait to come back next week and try Shepherds Pie and Ribs. I highly recommend this Pub.
