Location: Milton
Top Restaurants in Milton
Countries
Best American food near Milton, Pennsylvania, United States
Best American restaurants nearby. Discover the best American food in Milton. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for American restaurants near you.. Milton is a borough in Northumberland County, Pennsylvania, on the West Branch Susquehanna River, 50 miles (80 km) north of Harrisburg. It is about 10 miles upriver from the mouth of the West Branch Susquehanna River and about 30 miles downriver of Williamsport.
Things to do in Milton
10. Bonanza
Overall Ratings
3 based on 65 reviews
Reviewed By daizymom
We stopped here on our way through- the service was quick and friendly and the food was great. Three of us went with the buffet, and 2 ordered the steak and shrimp entree. Steaks were a little over cooked but ok. The buffet had a great variety and the prices were great.
9. Arrowhead Drive-In Rest
Overall Ratings
3 based on 34 reviews
Reviewed By Wishwewerethere
Stopped in for lunch. The place was just a diner. It was a clean small town diner. The food just seemed to be lacking any pizzaz. The salad had a good crisp texture but nothing else. I had a chicken wrap was very plane. It is an ok clean meal but nothing fancy at all. Service was slow. Our waitress was also our cook. So don't expect anything to be quick. Our waitress was pleasant but overworked.
8. Reba and Pancho's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 170 reviews
Reviewed By sandralburg
This place never disappoints! More than great food, its an great experience. Definitely make a reservation as they are typically booked:)Thank you, youâre too kind. This review means the world to us, it has to be one of our favorites Weâre so happy to hear about all the great experiences you have with us. Honestly, thatâs why weâre here, itâs what we love to do. We are lucky to have guests like you. You provide us the motivation and means to continue pursuing our passion. Again, thank you, we hope you will allow us the pleasure of feeding you soon!We really care,The Team at Reba and Panchoâs
7. Good Wil's Restaurant & Bakery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
Reviewed By uptowndinergirl
Had dinner here, chicken and waffles with all the fixings. It tasted like my grandmothers. The restaurant was clean and busy. The service was friendly and prompt. Can't ask for more than that. I will be back.
6. Elizabeth's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 234 reviews
Elizabethâs is a true upscale bistro with casual dress, complete with good, hearty food made from the freshest ingredients. Our 110+ bottle wine list is sure to please any wine connoisseur. We have earned the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence since 2003.
Reviewed By JMUDuke
We decided to end our date night at Elisabethâs for dessert. It was the best decision we had made! Loved the apple cobbler and the cookies dessert. Both were fantastic. Service was wonderful, as always. We also had a very sweet out of town couple next to us that we engaged in conversation with. We are so glad you enjoyed your desserts at Elizabeth's. Remember all of our desserts are made in-house by Liz and they change frequently. Your coffee and Amaretto disaronno paired beautifully with your desserts. We also love when customers interact with one another, you may just make a new friend.
5. Sublicious
Overall Ratings
4 based on 29 reviews
Reviewed By RetiredLM
Nothng spectacular, good subs, feel pricing a little high- very small eat in area, sub selection good.
4. Matty's Sporthouse Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 244 reviews
Enjoy Mattyâs Sporthouse Grill, our sports themed casual dining place that is family oriented, offering weeknight food and drink specials. Take advantage of watching all your favorite sporting events on our 24 big screen tvâs while enjoying a drink in the
Reviewed By Mark G
We were staying in the Best Western Country Cupboard, so we just walked a short distance thru the parking lot and we were there. A recent storm had knocked out some of the power in the restaurant, but they were handling everything quite well. It is a spacious place with tiered seating down to the front wall with TV's everywhere. There is a nice oval bar as you walk in with high tops around it. My pork BBQ sandwich was loaded high with a good sauce and the in house chips were very good. You never know what you are going to get restaurant to restaurant because for some reason a lot of them can't seen to make them very well, and these were good. My wife liked her salad with salmon and our waitress was very friendly and efficient. We would definitey come back to Matty's if in the area again.
3. The Fence Drive In
Overall Ratings
4 based on 62 reviews
Reviewed By Kidsaregone65
The fence is a good place for a quick lunch. The fish sandwich was very good. The homemade tarter sauce is great. A sandwich with fries is a little under $6 which seemed reasonable.Being along the river, we had a great water view on a beautiful day.I plan to return to try other menu items also.
2. Country Cupboard
Overall Ratings
4 based on 677 reviews
A warm, inviting, family atmosphere awaits you - a place where you can relax, enjoy a great meal, browse through our Gift Shops, and take home delicious, fresh-baked goodies from our in-house bakery.
Reviewed By 13sherryr
The big diningroom is nice if you are going to have buffet or want to sit in a more elegant atmosphere, but the little diner area just outside the big diningroom is very cozy and better lit. The servers are very friendly and attentive. There is a bar for solo seating or if the tables/booths are full. The booths are especially nice because they are extra wide. Menu is the same as in the big diningroom.
What to do and see in Milton, United States: The Best Places and Tips
1. Lisaâs Milltown Deli
Overall Ratings
4 based on 146 reviews
Reviewed By Michael R
We were on a 10-hr drive along I-80 and it was lunchtime as we were approaching the Milton exit, so a quick on line search suggested Lisa's Milltown Deli might be a good place to go. It looked promising. Large menu with a good variety of choices, and we could eat outside cafe style. My wife had the turkey-cranberry-brie panini while I had the "Montana" panini (turkey, bacon, cheese, tomato, avocado, ranch dressing) and a side of coleslaw. The sandwiches were generously sized. My wife felt her sandwich was a bit bland. I liked mine just fine, but the coleslaw was ridiculous. It tasted like coleslaw but consistency was a finely ground slurry of very tiny coleslaw particles. I have to think this was from the very bottom of the giant barrel of coleslaw. Sitting on the sidewalk was nice but every car that parked next to us, the drivers left the car idling and throwing off noise and heat while they went inside to pick up their carryout, which wasn't that pleasant. And being outside allowed our waitress to forget we existed pretty much constantly, including after I asked for a coffee top up (which I didn't get). So lunch took a solid hour. Lunch for two came to $30 with tax and tip which seemed like a lot for what we got. So the food was indifferent, service was poor, and it was a bit overpriced, but still better than the fast food place around the corner.
Milton Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Milton
