Location: Gap
Top Restaurants in Gap
Top Things to do in Gap
Countries
Best American food near Gap, Pennsylvania, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in Gap, Pennsylvania, United States. Gap is a census-designated place and community in Salisbury Township, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania with a ZIP code of 17527. The population was 1,931 at the 2010 census. U.S. Route 30 passes through the town, which is also the terminus for four Pennsylvania highways: 772, 741, 897, and the heavily used 41, which goes toward Wilmington, Delaware.
Things to do in Gap
10. The Olde Mill Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 563 reviews
Olde Mill Restaurant is committed to celebrating the history, heritage and hospitality that have been a part of the town of Intercourse in Lancaster, PA for more than 200 years. Their combination of delicious homemade food, incredibly friendly staff and
Reviewed By lather66
First visit while in area. Limited menu. I had meatloaf which had sausage in it, menu did not mention that. I do not like sausage. Bread filling was nothing but grilled potato bread cubed, no flavor. I swear the "mashed potatoes " were leftover baked potatoes, smashed, placed in a mold and dumped on plate. Also did not like. Husband had fried chicken and said it was good but very salty. Corn fritters and iced tea were good. Server was friendly and efficient. Much better PA Dutch for elsewhere. I would not return Dear Lather66, Thank you for taking the time to offer us your review . I do apologize you did not enjoy your meal with us . I assure you our meatloaf is not made with sausage and our mashed potatoes are made from Yukon gold potatoes and we leave the skin on them. We are please to hear our server was friendly and efficient and I hope you will give us another opportunity to provide you with excellent service and product.
9. Bullfrog Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 54 reviews
Reviewed By david v
Still struck by the surroundings. In the midst of Amish country, surrounded by horse & buggies, is this place, not looking like much from the outside, where I could absolutely eat every night.Everything we ordered was absolutely superb. Start with the beers. Being from the Live Free or Die state, I ordered the Brew Free or Die beer, with blood orange, and heart enough with a 7% alcohol level. We had the lager mushrooms for an appetizer...deep-fried and excellent. My wife's Whiskey Chicken sandwich (she often orders chicken sandwiches) was the best chicken sandwich she's ever had. My pot roast sandwich was excellent...never had anything like it. We got a basket of fries as a side, and would certainly recommend you do the same. They were very good. And then, after we had already been delivered the bill, ordered raspberry pie for dessert....came with a scoop of ice cream on each side.Service was excellent, very pleasant. If in the area again, I will definitely be back.
8. Harvest Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 257 reviews
In the Harvest Café youâll find plenty of options for lunches and snacks. Every day we make homemade soups like chicken corn or cream of broccoli. Juicy burgers are featured each day with a variety of toppings. Our fresh cut fries make the perfect complim
Reviewed By 13les13
The Harvest Cafe is a must try. The food is fresh and delicious. The turkey on their sandwich is fresh turkey, not processed. The chicken salad wrap with the cranberry relish is very tasty. There is ample seating available, but this place gets very busy and you may have a bit of a wait during peak times...but it is worth it. The place is kept clean with an extremely friendly staff. It is a pleasure to go there.This has become my favorite go to place.
7. Amos' Place
Overall Ratings
4 based on 117 reviews
Visit Amosâ Place; a delightful restaurant area with indoor and outdoor seating for your comfort and pleasure. Place your order and take a seat. Whether youâre in the mood for a warm grilled cheese and homemade soup or a fresh Caesar salad, we have menu i
Reviewed By C5339JDjeanb
Great sandwiches and friendly service. This is a nice place to eat if you just want a really good, inexpensive, quick, simple lunch. My husband and I split a chicken salad wrap and it was excellent, very fresh veggies and lots of flavor. We would definitely recommend stopping in and not just shopping the market side, which is exceptional on its own, but stopping in Amoâs and getting a bite to eat. We have eaten here many times and have never been disappointed. Everything weâve tried has been great. The portions large and the prices reasonable. This is very apparent when you see all the locals eating here. It is definitely worth a try. Thank you so much for your kind words! I will make sure to pass your comments along to the manager and employees at Amos' Place :) We're glad that you've enjoyed every visit that you've had with us, and hope to see you again soon!
6. Kling House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 547 reviews
The Kling House Restaurant is the home of Kitchen Kettle Village in Intercourse, PA. The house nurtured three generations of Klings and Burnleys before the Lancaster County farmhouse became a restaurant. The front porch, living room, dining room and offic
Reviewed By Linda F
Having read the reviews for Kling House, we stopped there for lunch. The chicken salad sandwich with (extra) sweet potato fries was enough for my husband and I to split. Service was friendly and the food was fresh and delicious. Good respite in a touristy area. Would definitely recommend this place.
5. DETZIS TAVERN
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By Allansha
They have some excellent dishes and are very busy in the early evenings from 5-7. The crowds are mostly locals. Who are loyal. Customers for multiple trips a weekFood is generally good with large portions. Prices are quite reasonable and service sometimes is amiss but it is fun
4. Brass Eagle Inn
Overall Ratings
3 based on 82 reviews
Reviewed By Keith Alan A
We were looking for a place near Intercourse, where we were staying, to get early drinks and dinner at a reasonable price.It seemed from their website that the restaurant had a happy hour, so we headed out. When we arrived, we asked the hostess in the restaurant if Happy Hour was still on, and she looked at us like we were speaking Martian, and said "..uh..uh.. no". Apparently she knew nothing about the bar around back and downstairs which DID have a happy hour.We decided to have dinner anyway and asked our waitress why the hostess knew nothing about a happy hour, and she informed us there was a bar around back and downstairs, so we thanked her and went around to check it out.As soon as we opened the door we turned right around and left as the smell of cigarettes came streaming out of the place. We did not know that Pennsylvania allowed smoking in bars, so were not willing to endure it for a drink. So we went back upstairs.The menu was OK.. nothing special. I had veal parmiagiana and my wife had chicken parmigiana. Both were decent meals at reasonable prices. The service was a little slow but not bad. All in all the experience was fine but not exceptional. Also had a decent red wine with the meal. Again, just average.If you don't mind smoke, go ahead downstairs and tell us what it was like. Otherwise, stay upstairs for a decent and reasonable family meal, if you aren't looking for fine dining.
3. Aunt Jennie's 41 Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 58 reviews
Reviewed By DVClippingdale
This diner is a typical diner. The food is affordable and the portions are generous. It will fill your belly and not empty your wallet. The decor is dated, the seats need to be reupholstered and the menus need to be cleaned off. There is plenty of parking and the place is easy to get to. If you are looking for a fine dining experience, just drive past this diner.
2. Dutch-Way Family Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 44 reviews
Reviewed By Lancaster_Expert
This small restaurant largely skipped my attention until some friends recommended the reasonably priced buffet. We tried it out on seafood night, which is around $22 per person, with an additional $10 per person for the crab legs upgrade. We chose not to do the upgrade on this trip. Pros: Nice family dining atmosphere, good service, and friendly staff. Reasonable prices, and a buffet with all the essentials. Even though we dined on seafood night, there was still plenty of fried chicken, meatloaf, ham loaf, and sides. Also, soups and a dessert bar. Cons: The seafood offerings (aside from crab legs) were kind of basic. Several types of shrimp, clam strips, some filets, "crab" salad. There was an empty pan of blackened salmon that did not get refilled. I was impressed they had mussels.The fried chicken was dry, although my 7 year old loved it. My husband really enjoyed eating here and we will definitely be back soon. I love that it's a smaller restaurant with mostly local customers. There was no lines or buses. It was busy but also quieter than the bigger buffets. Overall, it's a winner.
What to do and see in Gap, United States: The Best Places and Tips
1. White Horse Luncheonette
Overall Ratings
4 based on 70 reviews
Reviewed By Joni S
A friendly local recommend stopping here for lunch one day. Hubby and I both wanted a lighter lunch so we chose soup. He had beef noodle soup and my choice was a cheeseburger potato soup. They were delicious! Hot and filling plus we had a friendly waitress and the menu offered reasonable prices. Can't wait to stop in again when we visit the area.
Gap Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Gap
