Location: Fish Creek
Top Restaurants in Fish Creek
Countries
Best American food near Fish Creek, Wisconsin, United States
Find out what American restaurants to try in Fish Creek. Fish Creek is an unincorporated community located in Door County, Wisconsin, United States, within the town of Gibraltar and is located on Highway 42 along Green Bay.
Things to do in Fish Creek
10. Bayside Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 507 reviews
Reviewed By Dennis D
Ate there one afternoon after shopping, looking for outdoor tables in the area. Once we walked inside, the bar atmosphere was hopping. The service, food, and drinks were outstanding. Will be back again...
9. Mr. Helsinki Restaurant & Wine Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 265 reviews
Reviewed By sandyCumming
After dinner my girlfriend suggested we go to Mr. Helsinki for a nightcap. We had not been there, or even knew where it was. I believe there's some kind of market on the first floor, and Mr. Helsinki is upstairs. Very unique place! We all had wine, and some laughs. The owner was there...very friendly. Might try dinner on our next visit.
8. Pelletier's Restaurant & Fish Boil
Overall Ratings
4 based on 638 reviews
Reviewed By R2Ontheroad
Another couple joined us and we stepped in and made a 5 pm supper reservation. Then we strolled to the nearby shops. Came back about 1/2 hour before the boil and secured our drinks and outside table. The weather was perfect. The cooking process was explained and the resulting meal was excellent. Highly recommend this to complete your Door County vacation.
7. The English Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 650 reviews
Reviewed By 931ah
We visited on the recommendation of a friend. Loved the old supper club decor and we were seated by a really friendly host. Our server was very personable however extremely scattered. We ordered their specialty the Beef Wellington and the outside looked beautiful but the filet was full of gristle and tasteless. The dough around it gummy. Au gratin potatoes had a watery cheese on them. In Wisconsin they should know of a cheese that melts well. The one thing that was spectacular was the cherry spinach salad with bacon dressing. Best ever! Ordered an old fashioned which tasted good but lacked alcohol. Ordered a martini next and it didnât have much booze in it either. It was hard to get a second drink. Our server kept whizzing by but never stopped. Dirty dishes sat on our table way too long. We thought about ordering dessert but feared another long wait so we got the very large tab and left.
6. The Cookery Restaurant and Wine Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1034 reviews
Family run restaurant offering American casual fare with an emphasis on local ingredients. Breakfast, lunch and dinner are served daily. Water view wine bar, featuring weekly lively music, and daily happy hour from 3 to 6 p.m. Vegetarian and gluten free s
Reviewed By doengels
We arrived late on a Friday morning and were seated immediately. Our server was attentive, got us our beverages promptly, and gave us enough time to decide on our order without making us wait. My girlfriendâs omelet was beautifully prepared and substantial. My eggs were done just right and the biscuits were wonderful, as was the fruit jams to spread on them. The ham could have been warmer and the roasted American potatoes were good but not great. I couldnât help but wish Iâd gotten the hash browns instead even as my girlfriend kept taking them off my plate as they were just the thing sheâd wanted.A very good meal, a decent price, good service, and a tasty breakfast. We would go again.
5. Gibraltar Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 441 reviews
Reviewed By R2Ontheroad
The restaurant is in an excellent location. We were seated inside and had good service. The Mediterranean pasta was excellent.
4. Julie's Park Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 987 reviews
Julie's Park Cafe and Motel is a traditional American cafe that is set just outside Peninsula State Park and just at the north end of Fish Creek, WI. Minutes from shops, beaches, water, parks, and bike rentals. We love to accommodate any and everyone that
Reviewed By Marianne D
Enjoyed breakfast at Julie's this past Sunday. Cute place, very friendly staff and excellent food. It was raining so there wasn't a big crowd waiting to get in but have heard it's pretty popular so would suggest planning accordingly.
3. Alexander's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 623 reviews
Reviewed By Gwen W
While staying with my sister in Egg Harbor, we had to visit Alexander's again, since I enjoyed it so much last year. The bartenders are friendly, so we decided to once again enjoy dinner at the large bar area. The Manhattans here are excellent, although I wish they would serve a Luxor cherry. I enjoyed the Door County broiled Whitefish, served with a salad, a potato and a vegetable and only around $20.00-amazing!And I would be remiss if I did not mention their signature drink-the Brandy Alexander-be sure to order one after dinner-yummy!
2. Wild Tomato Wood Fired Pizza and Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1943 reviews
We are a family owned and operated fresh new restaurant with, not only great wood-fired pizzas, salads, sandwiches and burgers, but also a new attitude toward giving to their community, using sustainable products and creating an affordable restaurant usin
Reviewed By terrain6
Great wood fired pizza. Large outdoor seating area. The seating inside is somewhat small. The cherry walnut salad was delicious. Everyone was very friendly and willing to please. If you like good pizza and salad I highly recommend the Wild Tomato.
1. White Gull Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1371 reviews
Award-winning restaurant open to the public. Winner of Good Morning America's Best Breakfast Award. Sumptuous lunches, candlelight dinners and famous for traditional Door County whitefish boils. Open all year.
Reviewed By Tommy W
Let me start off by saying we just ate here....we did not stay here. My wife and some friends came to this restaurant on the advice of our friends. It's very nicely appointed. The wait staff are very friendly. And our food was very tasty. I had the eggs Benedict and it was great. My wife's sandwich was great (I can not remember what it was), and our friends meals were very good too. We all shared a piece of cherry coffee cake...yes it was big enough for all four of us, and it too was very good. The area around the Inn was beautiful, and there were lots of shops to explore. We would definitely come back and eat here again.Thank you, Tommy. We are so pleased you enjoyed the whole experience with us! Our homemade coffee cake is the perfect size for sharing!
