Location: Custer
Top Restaurants in Custer
Countries
Best American food near Custer, South Dakota, United States
Reviews on American food in Custer, South Dakota, United States. Enveloped in the grandeur of the Black Hills, Custer makes the perfect base for your South Dakota vacation, whether you are visiting Custer State Park to learn about Custer's Last Stand, heading up to see the wonder of Mount Rushmore and the yet-unfinished Crazy Horse Memorial, making a motorcycle pilgrimage to Sturgis or spelunking in Wind Cave. Custer itself has much to offer, from family outings at Flintstones Bedrock City to hoe-down dinners at a chuck wagon cookout.
Things to do in Custer
10. Pizza Mill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 185 reviews
Hand Crafted Pizza, Sandwiches, Soup and Salads.
Reviewed By laphph2
Maybe my cheese pizza was not typical, but it was just average. OK, so I LOVE pizza and even average pizza is enjoyable to me, but when you lay out the cost/enjoyment ratio, it did not make my top 10 list. My DW, on the other hand, really enjoyed her veggie pizza. DW wants to go back, but Id rather try another place in town for comparison sake. I would not suggest you avoid it on my word, but temper your expectations.
9. Sylvan Lake Lodge
Overall Ratings
4 based on 304 reviews
Reviewed By MNnola
We stopped for lunch after navigating Iron Mt. Rd. Service was friendly and prompt. Our lodge salad was delicious and we enjoyed a turkey sandwich. The restaurant is lovely with large windows. We had a satisfying and tasty meal. Unfortunately, there was trouble with the computer and we had to wait about 20 minutes to pay. We were able to sit out by the roaring fire and enjoyed chatting with other travelers - but if we had been on a tight schedule it would have been a problem.
8. State Game Lodge Dining Room
Overall Ratings
4 based on 530 reviews
Reviewed By David W
We ate here a couple times during our visit to the Lodge and park. The food was good but the menu was limited and higher than expected. This was probably higher priced because of the limited competition and the relative isolation of the property. If you are staying at the Lodge, this is about your only choice within an hour.
7. Buglin' Bull Restaurant and Sports Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1584 reviews
Family-friendly restaurant and sports bar located downtown Custer, SD. New upper deck open in 2012. Large menu has something for everyone in the family - delicious sandwiches, best buffalo burgers in the Black Hills, salads, wraps, pizza, pasta, steaks an
Reviewed By spiritwheels
This is a good place for lunch. I had the burger and fries and was very happy with it. Itâs a sports bar so there were tv screens to watch most sporting events.Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review! We're glad to hear that you enjoyed your visit and hope to have you back again soon!
6. Dakota BBQ
Overall Ratings
5 based on 92 reviews
We are a quick service, limited seating BBQ restaurant In the beautiful southern Black Hills of South Dakota. We are currently open for Wednesday through Saturday, 11am MST until SOLD OUT. We also have a second location at 12279 Brady Drive, Custer, SD 57
Reviewed By Thor1412
This is a small family owned business. They are extremely accommodating. The cost is not cheap but the servings are huge. Pig out here! All the BBQ meals tasted fantastic. All people who like to âeat savory BBQ meatâ need to eat here.
5. Blue Bell Lodge - Tatanka Dining
Overall Ratings
4 based on 551 reviews
Reviewed By Lynn W
We stopped in for lunch on our way through the park. The host seated us fairly quick and our waitress, Jazelle (??) came to take our drink orders within a couple of minutes. I ordered the COB (cheddar, caramelized onions and bacon hamburger) with home fries and my friend ordered the "Prospector" burger (Swiss cheese & mushrooms) with fries, $30. The food was great, the service not so. Jazelle didn't check on us much or refill our drinks. The dining room wasn't that busy. I will probably give it another chance if I return to the area.
4. Sage Creek Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 751 reviews
Reviewed By Jpamr5
We ate dinner at Sage Creek Grille on Wednesday, August 21, 2019. Menu offerings were unique.We ordered the bleu cheese bruschetta and wild sockeye salmon melt. Both were very tasty. The bruschetta was a little heavy on the bleu, so need to really like bleu cheese to enjoy it.Service was excellent. Atmosphere is pleasant. A really good local spot to enjoy.
3. The Custer Wolf - Food & Drink
Overall Ratings
4 based on 196 reviews
Providing a fun, casual atmosphere with a focus on fresh made food and an exciting selection of beer and wine, The Custer Wolf is a favorite for locals and tourists looking for something a little different. Come in for a pint, delicious homemade food and
Reviewed By retiredandlovinit
Eclectic menu with nice options. We had the Cod over Vegetables as recommended by our waitress and it was superb. Great wine selection; Beer selection looked good too, but our group prefers wine. Had the dessert special...bread pudding...which normally we don't really care for. This too was excellent...crispy instead of soggy. We wish we would have time for a second visit!Thank you for your review. We're so glad you enjoyed our wine selection...most people know us by our beer but our wine is great too!
2. Black Hills Burger and Bun Co.
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1586 reviews
Reviewed By schleyrib
Visited this place around noon on October 3rd based on the recommendation of the gentleman at National Car Rental at the Rapid City Airport. Let me start by thanking him for the best recommendation ever. BHBB was packed with their lunch crowd, but we were seated after a short wait and greeted by a super friendly waitress. We started with cheese curds that were excellent. My wife ordered a standard cheeseburger and I ordered the Texan. Both burgers were cooked perfectly and seasoned to perfection. I also ordered a strawberry milk shake that was superior and filled with strawberries. Would recommend BHBB to anyone visiting the area. Now if they would only open a branch here in Illinois, I would be in heaven.
1. Skogen Kitchen
Overall Ratings
5 based on 285 reviews
We are a Chef driven restaurant, serving innovative breakfast and dinner option. Using local and fresh ingredients. While providing great customer service.
Reviewed By TurquoiseWaters92
Three of us recently had breakfast at Skogen. We had a wonderful time. The owners and staff were friendly and the food was exceptional. I especially liked the bottomless Mimosas.
