10 Top-Rated Hotels in Finger Lakes, New York

September 30, 2022 Florencio Paulino

New York’s Finger Lakes region takes its name from 11 freshwater lakes placed like a handprint between Lake Ontario and the Pennsylvania border. Skiing, hiking and biking trails traverse the landscape; visitors can also indulge in various wine, cheese and beer trails. The area offers a culinary bounty, with an emphasis on farm-to-table cuisine. Rich history and culture are found throughout the region, with one attraction more inviting than the next.
Things to do in Finger Lakes

1. Holiday Inn & Suites Syracuse Airport - Liverpool, an IHG Hotel

400 7th North St, Liverpool, Salina, NY 13088
Excellent
79%
Good
11%
Satisfactory
4%
Poor
3%
Terrible
3%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 1704 reviews

Holiday Inn & Suites Syracuse Airport - Liverpool, an IHG Hotel

Holiday Inn & Suites Syracuse Airport - Liverpool is by design your home while you are visiting Syracuse. The hotel offers kitchenettes in all guestrooms, complimentary hot breakfast, wireless Internet everywhere, and after a long day you can cool off in the brand new indoor pool. Be sure to check out the state of the art fitness center featuring treadmills, elliptical machines, free weights and more. At the crossroads of the New York State Thruway and Route 81, you are available to escape with ease and travel to the West towards Niagara Falls, or towards the East to New York City. North from this location is Watertown and Fort Drum, while you can travel South to Ithaca and Binghamton. We are just minutes from Syracuse Hancock International Airport, Destiny USA Shopping Center and the New York State Fairgrounds.

Wonderful!

Reviewed By hayleydL4932IL

We had the pleasure of staying at this hotel. Very friendly staff, clean and renovated! The front entrance staff, Sarah and Cam were hilarious and welcomed us right in! Would highly recommend staying here to anyone visiting the area!

2. Watkins Glen Harbor Hotel

16 N Franklin St, Watkins Glen, NY 14891-1221
Excellent
79%
Good
16%
Satisfactory
3%
Poor
1%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 1924 reviews

Watkins Glen Harbor Hotel

The Watkins Glen Harbor Hotel has been awarded a four diamond rating from AAA -The American Automobile Association. This distinction is given to hotels with refined and stylish accommodations and a high level of service and attention to detail. This award makes the Watkins Glen Harbor Hotel the top rated hotel in Watkins Glen, New York. At the Watkins Glen Harbor Hotel, our staff is proud to offer all our guests outstanding service! The hotel offers a variety of deluxe accommodations including six luxurious suites. We offer nightly turndown service, an indoor pool, fitness center and our professional concierge is on call to assist you and your family in planning your Watkins Glen vacation.

Wonderful Stay At Glen Harbor

Reviewed By Snowshadow

This was our first trip to the Finger Lakes and we were very happy with the area and the hotel. So much so, we are already planning our next trip back. This hotel and restaurant did not disappoint. Recommend getting a room on the lake side, absolutely fantastic view.

3. Country Inn & Suites by Radisson, Rochester-Pittsford/Brighton, NY

2835 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618-4133
Excellent
65%
Good
22%
Satisfactory
8%
Poor
2%
Terrible
3%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 316 reviews

Country Inn & Suites by Radisson, Rochester-Pittsford/Brighton, NY

Located near Interstates 390, 490 and 590, the Country Inn & Suites by Radisson, Rochester-Pittsford/Brighton, NY is the perfect place to ease off the road and recharge. In addition to being only minutes from the University of Rochester, our hotel is near three other colleges, including St. John Fisher College. Enjoy access to nearby restaurants, shops and downtown Rochester, as well.

Just ok

Reviewed By Shellington2001

This hotel could have been cleaner, fresher, & more updated. We weren’t sure about the area it was in, but after dinner and Crumbl cookies, we knew it could have been a better part of town. Continental breakfast was a cold one. For the money it was ok

4. Hampton Inn & Suites Syracuse North Airport Area

1305 Buckley Road, Salina, NY 13212 1 (855) 605-0317
Excellent
87%
Good
8%
Satisfactory
3%
Poor
1%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

5 based on 397 reviews

Hampton Inn & Suites Syracuse North Airport Area

Welcome to Hampton Inn & Suites Syracuse North Airport Area, located at Exit 36 off the New York State Thruway (I-90) and Exit 25 off I-81 in the suburb of Liverpool. We are just 3 miles south of the Syracuse Hancock International Airport with a free 24-hour airport shuttle. Our friendly staff works to ensure your stay is relaxing. Enjoy our free, hot breakfast daily or grab a Hampton On the Run® Breakfast Bag to take away with you, available Monday through Friday. Restaurants in walking distance include Salt City Grill, Denny's and Burger King. When you need a quick snack, stop by our 24-hour Suite Shop convenience store. The hotel features a conference room with A/V equipment for up 80 people. Stay on top of work in this Syracuse hotel's business center with fax, copying and printing capabilities. We provide recreation at our indoor heated pool and fitness center.

Hotel Chain continuously exceeds expectations

Reviewed By GetawayGal23

Newer hotel, well appointed rooms. Clean hot tub and pool area, but could use larger towels.Breakfast area is SPOTLESS and food choices are plentiful and continuously refilled. Coffee/tea/cocoa available 24 hours. Excellent staff

5. The Statler Hotel at Cornell University

130 Statler Dr, Ithaca, NY 14853-6901
Excellent
74%
Good
19%
Satisfactory
5%
Poor
1%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 904 reviews

The Statler Hotel at Cornell University

Offering a blend of campus energy and modern elegance, The Statler Hotel offers visitors and travelers an inviting atmosphere within a first-class hotel. Guest are minutes from Ithaca, NY and can take in the sights of the ever-beautiful Finger Lakes countryside.

Convenient for Cornell, but a little pricey

Reviewed By world t

Was visiting the campus in April 2022 so we wanted to stay at the Stadler Hotel: can't beat the convenience of being on campus. The hotel is fine--nothing notable, but still okay--and the rooms are tasteful albeit small. We had a pretty dismal view of a rooftop that obscured anything but the tips of some spires, but we liked the Cornell-themed bedding (and the beds were quite comfortable--we slept well after a red-eye that morning!). That said, there were some gaps. The valet was hit and miss--I feel for them, as the cars are pretty far away, but sometimes the wait was longer than promised even despite scanning in the QR code in advance. The bar was spotty but fine for a quick beer. Check-in was not super-pleasant, but the check-out staff was very kind. I have read these are all students, so I understand the variance of customer service. But for these prices, I'd just expect a little bit more consistency in the delivery.

6. La Tourelle Hotel, Bistro, Spa

1150 Danby Rd Route 96B, Ithaca, NY 14850-9406
Excellent
65%
Good
24%
Satisfactory
5%
Poor
4%
Terrible
2%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 730 reviews

La Tourelle Hotel, Bistro, Spa

If you're looking for a getaway that offers deluxe accommodations; fabulous food; great wine; a destination spa and adventure experiences all nestled in the gorgeous New York Finger Lakes wine region, you've found it! La Tourelle's 54 deluxe rooms have dreamy pillow-top mattresses to ensure a restful night's sleep. You'll need that sleep if you plan on touring the wine trails; visiting the museums; taking a hike in any of the five state parks, or participating in the numerous adventure excursions available in "gorges" Ithaca. After experiencing all that Finger Lakes wine country has to offer, you'll really appreciate getting pampered at August Moon Spa. We offer all the services you expect from a destination spa, plus we have two Tranquility Rooms where you can relax and enjoy cuisine from our "farm-to-table" menu at The Bistro.

Very nice older Boutique Style hotel

Reviewed By MaryAnn B

A very nice older hotel with a boutique feel. The staff were all very friendly and helpful. Our room was very large and nicely appointed. They are repairing the roof so there was some heavy equipment around, but it did not detract from a lovely experience. They offer a free glass of wine during a happy hour. The hotel has a very pretty setting and we would definitely stay there again,

7. Best Western Brockport Inn & Suites

4908 Lake Rd S, Brockport, NY 14420-2461 1 (833) 553-0631
Excellent
73%
Good
21%
Satisfactory
3%
Poor
2%
Terrible
2%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 440 reviews

Best Western Brockport Inn & Suites

Located in Brockport, NY, the Best Western Brockport Inn & Suites is sure to provide a peaceful and comforting home away from home for any traveler. Each Best Western hotel provides free internet access, giving guests the opportunity to check emails and surf the web, all from the comforts of their room or the business center. With cleanliness and value being our top priority, we ensure a restful and productive stay. On top of that, our superior customer service will ensure that we meet all your needs and go beyond your expectations.

Hope to Comeback Soon

Reviewed By Guillame2012

My kids wanted to go to the Strong Museum and we hit it big by choosing this hotel. The room was immaculate and modern. beds were comfy and soft. The air conditioner was quiet enough that I could sleep. There were 4 USB ports available to charge all of our devices. The shower pressure was better than in most hotels I've stayed in. There is no microwave in the rooms but one is available on the main floor. Free parking is provided. Their full hot breakfast provided a great selection of scrambled eggs, omelettes, sausages, hashbrowns, cereals, yogurts, muffins, and waffles which my kids loved. The most important part of our stay was the above-average guest service we received from the lady who served the breakfast and cooked extra sausages to the gentleman who gave my 2 sons balloons and filled them up to the general manager who helped me fix my son's watch, they went far above in providing great service making my kids happy and making us feel welcomed. They were simply awesome!!! The hotel is surrounded by a wooded area and open field which provides a quiet experience. It is only a 25 min drive into downtown Rochester. There is a Walmart around the corner if you need to pick up anything you need for your stay. I hope to book a stay at this hotel this summer when we come back to Rochester. Definitely consider this hotel!

8. Hampton Inn & Suites Syracuse Dewitt

3017 Erie Blvd E, Syracuse, NY 13224 1 (855) 605-0317
Excellent
57%
Good
29%
Satisfactory
9%
Poor
3%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 973 reviews

Hampton Inn & Suites Syracuse Dewitt

The Hampton Inn & Suites Syracuse Dewitt hotel is nestled just off major Interstate 690, with easy access to Interstates 90 & 81, as well. Our hotel is centrally located to meet the needs of any traveler. We are just moments from the Downtown Business District as well as Syracuse University & Lemoyne College. We are just a short drive from Carousel Center Mall, NYS Fairgrounds, museums, and parks. Our hotel is built on the very sight of the old Erie Canal, which was the main thoroughfare from Albany to Buffalo in the 1800's and early 1900's. This area of Syracuse is just a bustling today! Numerous restaurants, shopping, and entertainment for both adults & children are within walking distance of the hotel. The Syracuse area offers a lot of history as well. Take a trip to our Erie Canal Museum or Salt Museum and learn a little bit about Syracuse's past. If scenery is more your thing then visit our Onondaga Lake Park, Beaver Lake Nature Center, or Green Lakes State Park.

Excellent service

Reviewed By ttraveling

Awesome service on this visit! The front desk clerk sorted out a problem with our reservation, worked with housekeeping to get our room ready early, and accommodated a switch due to an HVAC issue - all in the busy week leading up to Syracuse graduation. The rooms have been refreshed since our last stay here and were very clean. Still not enough towel bars or hooks in the bathroom for more than 1 person but fortunately there are hooks in the room. (With housekeeping upon request during the stay, you need somewhere to hang your towel for re-use.) Breakfast was busy but sufficiently stocked. Easy drive to Syracuse campus and Westcott area, and also convenient to Cazenovia.

9. The Craftsman Inn & Suites

7300 E Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY 13066
Excellent
68%
Good
22%
Satisfactory
6%
Poor
2%
Terrible
1%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 211 reviews

The Craftsman Inn & Suites

Enjoyable Stay

Reviewed By Patricia M

My husband and I were traveling to the area for a concert and needed a place to stay with our dog. The room was clean and comfortable and the staff was very friendly. We had only a few issues during our stay. 1) The tv is across from the bed and not visible from the living area. We asked for someone to come and move it or move the huge mirror on the wall or provide another mirror so we could see what we were hearing from the living area and we were not accommodated. 2) The bathroom sink is too close to the toilet and I almost cracked my elbow on it several times. 3) There is alot of wasted empty floor space that could have been used to expand the average sized bathroom. 4) There was no staff at the front desk at night and noone answered the interior line when we called to ask questions. This made us feel unsafe and annoyed. 5) Lastly, we had dinner at the hotel restaurant on our first night there and everything came out cold and/or overdone. The manager quickly came over and apologized profusely and assessed whether we wanted new versions of what we had ordered or new items. We chose new items that were very tasty and we gobbled them up. I highly recommend the bone-in ribeye. I also highly recommend the drinks which were enjoyable throughout the evening. The manager that we worked with was Dan and he is in fact, the man. He comped half our bill and each time we ran into him throughout our weekend stay, he came right over to check on us. He made all the difference and I therefore can recommend that if you want a delightful meal with pleasant ambiance and friendly staff, try the Craftsman Inn's own beautiful restaurant. The outside patio alone is worth a few drinks. I also recommend Vito's which is a very close drive to this hotel and they have the most delicious italian food! Bon Apetit!

10. Comfort Inn & Suites

401 7th North St, Liverpool, Salina, NY 13088-6625
Excellent
73%
Good
14%
Satisfactory
7%
Poor
3%
Terrible
4%
Overall Ratings

4.5 based on 344 reviews

Comfort Inn & Suites

For a quiet and comfortable place to stay outside the bustle of downtown Syracuse, book a room at the Comfort Inn & Suites®, Syracuse North Airport, NY located at the intersection of I-81 and I-90 in Liverpool. Our hotel puts you less than two miles from name-brand retailers at Destiny USA and only three miles from Syracuse Hancock International Airport (SYR). Business guests appreciate our proximity to the trade shows at Empire Expo Center, and families love being near the festivals at Onondaga Lake and the diverse animals at Rosamond Gifford Zoo. After a day of meetings or exploring central New York, return to the hotel and recharge with free cookies and coffee in the lobby. You can work out in our on-site fitness center or put the finishing touches on a presentation in the business center before hosting a meeting in our event venue. Amenities and services include: Free Wi-Fi, Business Center, Fitness Center, Pet-Friendly, Free Parking, Complimentary Breakfast (grab and go bags during COVID-19 pandemic)

Scam!!!

Reviewed By W2905LIamyp

When we received our credit card statement for our stay in May 2022 they charged us $150 smoking fee. We have never smoked in our entire lives. We tried to contact the manager several (4) times and he never returned our calls. It sounds like a scam to get more money from their customers . We will never stay here again.

ThingsTodoPost © 2018 - 2024 All rights reserved.